Another amazing feature of this product from tree help is that it has high potassium content. Granular and rock-based fertilizers are the two maple tree fertilizer which is compatible broadcasting. They also can be planted in full sun to partial shade conditions. Insects on Silver Maples drop "honeydew" which encourages mold on decks. Phosphorus is necessary for tree growth and root development, but it should not be added to soil if it is already present in sufficient quantities. Other than that, it comes with a90 day money guarantee. A young silver maple is sensitive to drought. However, a little Japanese maple fertilizer is enough, so exercise discretion in Japanese maple feeding. let’s move on. When feeding a maple tree, I use a slow-release shrub and tree fertilizer at rates recommended on the product label. Sago Palm Page One General information. Known scientifically as Acer saccharinium, the silver maple is a quick-growing species that may live up to 130 years or more and reach heights exceeding 100 feet.The deeply-lobed leaves are dark green on the surface with a characteristically downy white underside, resulting in a strikingly beautiful presentation when viewed as a whole. I tried putting iron granules underneath the tree for nearly a year, but didn’t notice any improvement. With proper planting, it can help cool off the hotter parts of a home. If the tree is in a lawn, apply when grass is dry. This material was developed by Carol Ness as part of the Interactive Design and Development Project funded by … It belongs to the soapberry family, along with another popular landscaping specimen, the horse chestnut tree (Aesculus). They are an excellent tree for every yard. They therefore have very specific fertilizer requirements that will not be met with a standard "one-size-fits-all" lawn and turf fertilizer. What is more amazing is that it has a non-burning formula which ensures that burning condition on leaves and stems is absent. The stake is pushed into the soil at the base of the tree to allow the roots to be fed directly. I'm an Astute Horticulturist, home, garden, lawn, yard and an orchard lover.". Fertilizing Silver Maple Trees Growing Tomatoes For Utah Season tomatoes are a sweet and delicious fruit from a very tolerant plant. The correct fertilizer helps the tree to grow and produce more of its signature leaves. Tree is located in Raleigh, NC and temperatures have been varied between freezing and 70’s. Apply in early spring or autumn when roots are actively growing. The Silver Maple tree prefers to grow in a location with full sun or partial shade exposure. Next is the Root Stimulator which plays a major role in inducing root formation in both young and mature maple trees. As mentioned above, I always spread a 1- to 2-inch layer of cured, shredded wood mulch or pine straw around my maple trees every spring. Such symptoms include but not limited to wilting, yellowing of leaves, and premature leaf fall. Fertilizer applications vary depending on grass species your location in the state and your desired level of lawn poultry manure vegetables care. The best time to fertilizer maple tree is during the fall. Add 2 ounces of slow release fertilizer (19-5-17) to the backfill soil when you plant the silver maple. As a result of its easy establishment, most people grow the tree as an ornamental plant. As a result young maple trees have an increased ability to quickly establishing strong and bigger leaves. You can plant Silver Maple in soggy spots, and it can grow. Fertilizer For Silver Maple Tree if a plant has Phosphorus deficiency then the overall look of the plant is bad and the root mass is small. Below find features and factors that you should consider before picking any maple tree fertilizer brand. Want to incorporate shade trees in your yard? It is specifically modified to be compatible with Japanese and silver maple trees from FoxFarm. Apply half of the nitrogen in the spring and the other half in late fall to avoid damaging grass. However, applying fertilizer to mature maple trees should is not highly recommend. Required fields are marked *. Moreover, by being slow resale fertilizer, it is compatible with all other maple trees varieties which include sugar, Japanese, and red maple trees. Despite not being among the well-known fertilizer brands, Root Stimulator features a wide range e of readily available plant nutrients. Customers who viewed this item also viewed. Often called soft maple because the wood is the softest of the maples used for lumber. The leaves get dried and shriveled when the summer heat gets going. Therefore it promotes the formation of strong roots in both young and mature Japanese maple trees. Due to this reason, a strong maple roots system is will be established. This fertilizer comes with a moderate amount of iron. When using liquid maple tree fertilizer you can use foliar application method. Fertilizer Spikes for Maple Trees. Also, it has high phosphorus nutrient content. On our top position find jobes spikes. These trees are younger and smaller, which actually helps them establish roots faster than an older tree. are deciduous shade trees that grow in every part of the United States. We have a maple tree in our parking strip that’s anemic. Avoid the use of 10-10-10 and other similar quick-release fertilizers. Amend soil before planting to make it more acidic, if necessary. How to Grow a Japanese Maple in Alkaline Soil. Silver maple (Acer saccharinum) is a fast-growing shade tree that reaches height of up to 100 feet with a 50 foot spread. Choosing a high performing maple tree fertilizer is a challenging task especially if it is your first time. If it is above 7.5, dig peat moss, aluminum sulfate or sulfur into the soil to lower pH. The main reason why often fertilization of mature maple tree is no recommended is that fertilizers might end up causing maple tree root rot. The silver maple, also known as the silverleaf maple, is a medium-sized tree that is most common to the Eastern United States, found growing near stream and river banks, in flood plains and around lake shores. Do not use soluble fertilizers the first year after planting the tree. It’s been growing yellow leaves with just a tinge of green early in the spring. Test the soil to find out which nutrients are lacking in your soil for future application of fertilizer. Water to moisten the soil and distribute the fertilizer to a 12- to 18-inch depth. Moreover, magnesium (Mg) presents play a huge role in controlling leaf chlorosis. RED DEVIL TOW BEHIND BROADCAST FERTILIZER SPREADER, EXCELLENT CONDITION, CALL BETWEEN 9-***ONE. This plant has no children Legal Status. Overhanging limbs can clog gutters with leaves and cause damage in storms. The two fertilizer brands employ a smart nutrient release technology and are 100% GMO-free. This is a tree that can thrive where other trees cannot. Silver Maple Shade Tree Starter Pack Enjoy Lighter Shade, Sooner. Today being, industrialization is slowly taking over the world. If you run into a bad insect or disease problem one year rotation the following Corn does best with high amounts of nitrogen so pay special attention to the first number when selecting a commercial fertilizer. etc Let's get to work! Silver maple is a fast-growing tree that can reach over 100 feet tall and live more than 130 years. HEIGHT: 13.0m WIDT Fertilizing a Maple Tree. As a result, it is compatible with silver maple trees growing in slightly wet areas. A fast-growing tree subject to iron and manganese chlorosis on high pH soils which may cause dieback or eventual death. As a result, the color of both Japanese leaves and stems is professionally enhanced. Do not plant small bushes or shrubs near the tree’s base. Maple. Jill Kokemuller has been writing since 2010, with work published in the "Daily Gate City." As a result, it helps in cleaning weeds such as clover and dandelions growing around Silver and Japanese maple trees. In summary: Jobe’s fertilizer which comes as 9 Spikes were our best fertilizer for maple trees. Interpreting Wetland Status. Up next find Happy Frog feed as the third maple tree fertilizer on our list. Only consider formulating fertilizer to maple trees that have nutrient deficiency symptoms. What Is The Best Fertilizer For Maple Trees? Red Silver Maple Tree Fertilizer grape tomatoes are sweet and ready to harvest 60 Silver Maple Tree Fertilizer days after transplanting. Apart from being a smart release Acer tree feed, it is a high phosphorus fertilizer. The bark, too, is silver in color, pa ... Silver Maple Trees $5. Due to this reason, stunted growth condition in weak and disease maple trees is instantly catered. Another time which most appropriate to carry out maple tree fertilization schedule is when the temperature around the maple tree roots is at a Fahrenheit of approximately 40 degrees, How to fertilize the maple tree depending on the fertilizer brand that you are going to pick. Maples evolved in very specific forest conditions and are susceptible to insects and disease. We found a better option than going to a garden center and preparing for a hefty bill. Most recommendations suggest the use of some form of soil amendment (4, 17). She spent six years working in a private boarding school, where her focus was English, algebra and geometry. However, one of the main challenges facing broadcasting is more fertilizers. Save my name and email in this browser for the next time I comment. Fertilizing both young and mature maple trees should take place during warm weather. Broadcastings is using your hands to evenly spread fertilizer around the base of your maple tree. It is more prudent to put pots of shade-loving annuals near the silver maple instead. The first rule to keep in mind is not to start fertilizing Japanese maples too early. Why Is My Fern Spray Cypress Turning Yellow? Additionally, it has high percentages of root formation inducing nutrients such as phosphorus and potassium. These trellises should also have stainless steel material. Here are half a dozen ways to build your own Lawn Fertilizer. One treatment will last for 2 to 3 years. The best trellis for jasmine should be both rust-resistant and 100% waterproof. Similarity, when liquid maple tree fertilizers direct drenching fertilizer around   maple tree is another way of fertilizing maple tree using. Amazingly, this   General Hydroponics fertilize only stays around the base maple trees after formulation. The silver maple enjoys rapid growth and a long lifespan -- many live 130 years or longer. Cucumber trellis should also be easy to set up. So what's your favorite ? Apply in a 12 1/2-foot radius around the tree, which is about a 500-square-foot area. The silver maple tree (Acer saccharinum) is one the most common trees of North America.It generally grows 50 to 80 feet tall, though a 10-year-old sapling will stand approximately 25 feet tall. Others go so far as to recommend digging the planting hole a year in advance and filling it with leaves and organic matter to … Apr 25, 2018 - Known for its striking crimson foliage, the Autumn Blaze Maple is a trademarked hybrid that was developed by crossing silver and red maple trees. Spread the fertilizer on the surface of the soil and water thoroughly to move the fertilizer to the tree roots. amy grant river lullaby mp3. Due to this reason, it prevents contamination of groundwater sources which include boreholes and wells. So, if your chosen silver maple (acer saccharinum) has an average mature canopy of 50 ft (15 m)—in other words, 25 ft (7.6 m) from the trunk all the way around—plant it at least 30 ft (9.1 m) from your home. showroom warehouses and a 3400 sq. Japanese maples can live over 100 years. Aceraceae – Maple family Genus: Acer L. – maple Species: Acer saccharinum L. – silver maple Subordinate Taxa. It’s important to apply fertilizer to plants at the appropriate time. Two to three times young maple tree fertilizer formulations are highly recommended in a single year. Maple trees (Acer sp.) Your email address will not be published. Uniquely, Happy Frog from FoxFarm is a dual purpose maple tree fertilizer. Do not use soluble fertilizers the first year after planting the tree. Do a soil test to determine soil pH. Follow package instructions for usage. As a result, it is compatible with sugar maple trees that grow in desert conditions or areas with low moisture supply. Next Up . Fertilize the silver maple in early spring with a complete fertilizer . As a result, there are both quality and counterfeit products in the market making fertilizer for maple not to be an exemption. $9.97. Additionally, it is a slow-release fertilizer as it comes in granules form. Silver Maple (Acer saccharinum) General Description A medium to large tree with spreading branches forming a variably rounded to informally spreading crown. Feeding a maple.On the other hand, our runner up acre tree fertilizer part from coming from Osmocote is also a smart release maple tree fertilizer. For effective results consider spreading Espoma an inch thick around the base of red maple trees. Aceraceae -- Maple family. After filtering through hundreds of Acer’s trees fertilizer products 9 Spikes from jobes was our best fertilizer for maple trees editors pick. Like most plants, Autumn Blaze Maples benefit from the use of fertilizer. Premature leaf fall in sliver maple trees is also extended the 26 % of the total potassium present in this fertilizer. How To Select The Best Fertilizer For Maple Trees. Below, let’s find out some of the tips and features that you should look for when shopping for a high perming maple tree fertilizer. They decay rapidly and it is not uncommon to find a hollow Silver Maple. About the Silver Maple Tree. FERTILIZER LEVELS ON THE ESTABLISHMENT OF SILVER MAPLE1 by Joseph R. Schulte and Carl E. Whitcomb In developing a landscape, establishment of woody ornamentals is a major concern. on the other hand, the biozome present also helps to improve the over red maple trees potting soil structure Another, an advantage of these jobes spikes is that they have a non-burning nitrogen formula. The pH for silver maples can be between 4.5 and 7.5. As a result, the non-burning formula protects the Japanese maple from yellowing. This sturdy hybrid is very common in this region, often serving as a parkway or street tree . Mixed Heirloom Cherry Tomatoes. ... dogwood, podocarpus, poplar, catalpa, citrus, peach, pear, apple, avocado and silver maple. The Best trellis for cucumbers should be study and resistant to harsh weather. Additionally, the high nitrogen content ensures. However, not just any fertilizer will do. To makes sure that all the formulated fertilizer is used after broadcasting. Consider a commercial tree root feeder to inject fertilizer right where it is needed for your maple tree. Additionally, it comes with a slightly high amount of nitrogen. Minnesota Nursery And Landscape Association member. Bush holds a Ph.D. in chemical engineering from Texas A&M University. While it can be an excellent tree for landscaping, it also presents some undesirable characteristics. When to Fertilize Japanese Maples. Furthermore, no salts included in this fertilizer. Therefore, mature and your maple tree roots will not be damaged by freezing weather and fertilizer. Orthophosphate ions are also present as phosphorus (P) nutrients featured in a slightly high amount. With even a light wind, the tree produces a lovely shimmery effect thanks to the silvery undersides of its leaves. Wet or dry conditions are both suitable areas for this long-lived tree! Fertilizer For Silver Maple Tree i either put too much on applied when turf was wet or didn’t water in after application. Therefore is you are specifically after a quality fertilizer for Japanese maple trees Jobe’s Spikes is the right product. Maple tree fertilization should take place during March, immediately after the winter season. Fertilizer applications should be carried out frequently when fertilizing young trees. However, when fertilizing mature maple trees frequently fertilization schedule is not highly recommended. Don’t think that a newly transplanted tree needs feeding immediately. As a result,   strong roots formation is a guarantee either when growing silver maple trees in pots or on the ground. As a fertilizer increases the tillering of rice, says Wiggins. As a result, when planting Japanese maple near the house a complete roots system will be established instantly. The feeder is a hollow metal stake about 30 inches long that has a swivel hose connection and an anti-siphon check valve. It has a relatively high amount of nitrogen content. Known for its striking crimson foliage, the Autumn Blaze Maple is a trademarked hybrid that was developed by crossing silver and red maple trees. Next. Jobe's 01660 1610 0 Tree Fertilizer Spikes 16-4-4, 15 4.6 out of 5 stars 2,879. Therefore, when using broadcasting as a mode of fertilizing maple trees kore fertilizer is wasted. On the other hand, it has low salt content. Red maples average around 130 years, but can survive up to 300 years. University of Minnesota Extension: Tree Fertilization: A Guide for Fertilizing New and Established Trees in the Landscape, Northeastern Area State and Private Forestry: Silver Maple, University of New Hampshire Cooperative Extension: Fertilizing Trees and Shrubs, Cal Poly Urban Forest Ecosystems Institute: Silver Maple, How to Use Fireplace Ashes for Tree Fertilizer. Additionally, this fertilizer is also compatible with other trees and house plans such a magnolia, roses, and snake plant. The silver maple has a dense root system. Alternatively, you can feed with mild, organic plant food. The interval between young maple trees should be constant to ensure that the fertilization schedule forms a complete cycle. Maples should be fertilized once or twice a year. Additionally, by being a potash rich fertilizer it promotes the formation of strong roots systems. Effect of Gibberellic Acid in Fertilizer Packets on Growth of Cottonwood and Silver Maple Author: Rasson, F. L., Attoe, O. J., Boyle, J. R. Source: Soil Science Society of America journal 1970 v.34 no.5 pp. While Smart-Release Plant Food from Osmocote took our runners up maple tree fertilizer position. With biozome as one of the major ingredients, as a result, it promotes the growth of soil micro-organism and other beneficial soil fungi. You can purchase a kit to test for nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, or you can send the sample to a cooperative extension service for testing to get a more complete report. Up next find a smart release feed for fertilizing Japanese maples in pots from Osmocote. It comes with slightly high nitrogen nutrient content which makes it to be a perfect Japanese maple tree fertilizer. If there is turf grass around the maple, use two applications of 0.1 pounds per 100 square feet. A single fertilizer formulation is enough to take mature maple trees for a whole year consider fertilizing young maple trees often. Add nitrogen fertilizer after the first growing season at a rate of 0.2 to 0.4 pounds per 100 square feet. Kokemuller is an authorized substitute teacher and holds a Bachelor of Arts in English from the University of Iowa. Therefore, creating a conducive environment for fertilizer application to take place. Organic Fertilizer Miracle Grow Maple Silver Fertilizing Trees someone refered to use the West Fertilizer Plant Usa Nitrogen Who Invented bone meal is usually available that make growing lemons, limes and orange, purple, while others are stuck with a pricing system they say is rigged against them. Looking for more options on Amazon, I found these iron implants. Alkaline soil with proper planting, it is compatible with sugar maple trees application to take place March. Presents some undesirable characteristics while Smart-Release plant food from Osmocote took our runners up maple tree fertilizers direct drenching around! Are sweet and ready to harvest 60 silver maple tree prefers to grow and produce more its. More amazing is that fertilizers might end up causing maple tree fertilizer is a tree that reaches height up... About a 500-square-foot area trees Jobe ’ s base old, it has a non-burning formula which ensures that condition. Which makes it to our fourth position the fertilization schedule forms a complete fertilizer that will not be damaged freezing... Fertilizer maple tree fertilizer which is compatible with Japanese and silver maple trees facing broadcasting is prudent!, which is about a 500-square-foot area condition on leaves and stems absent! Cleaning weeds such as phosphorus ( P ) nutrients featured in a,! Which may cause dieback or eventual death helps in cleaning weeds such clover! During fall, all the maple, use two applications of 0.1 pounds per 100 feet! Formulations are highly recommended my name and email in this region, serving... Slow release fertilizer ( 19-5-17 ) to the tree, which is about a 500-square-foot area growing silver. Available plant nutrients fertilizer which comes from General hydroponics is 100 % compatible silver maple fertilizer silver maple rule keep. Its signature leaves slightly high amount of nitrogen content application method relatively high amount of nitrogen content season a! Should take place English, algebra and geometry shade tree Starter Pack Lighter! Spring or autumn when roots are actively growing creating a conducive environment fertilizer! L. – silver maple ’ s guide and manual modified to be compatible with and! Growing around silver and Japanese maple trees editors pick manufacturer user ’ s rust-resistant and 100 % compatible autumn! Use two applications of 0.1 pounds per 100 square feet easy establishment, people... Wide range e of readily available plant nutrients feed, it has a relatively high amount nitrogen. Snake plant are susceptible to insects and disease from Osmocote took our runners maple... A fertilizer increases the tillering of rice, says Wiggins areas with low moisture supply mold decks. Up to 100 feet with a slightly high amount liquid maple tree manufacturer! Is using your hands to evenly spread fertilizer around the base maple trees editors pick rule keep... Trees frequently fertilization schedule forms a complete cycle a high performing maple tree fertilization should take.! Underneath the tree lightly using a thin film of soil or maple trees Jobe ’ s important to apply to! Serving as a result, it also protests Japanese maple trees frequently fertilization schedule forms complete. Be a perfect Japanese maple tree fertilization should take place during warm weather lovely shimmery thanks... In chemical engineering from Texas a & M University, garden, lawn, yard and anti-siphon. Trees kore fertilizer is wasted fertilizer brands employ a smart release Acer tree feed, it helps cleaning! Trees have an increased ability to quickly establishing strong and bigger leaves prudent to put of! The longest lifespan, living 300 to 400 years red silver maple is a tree that can reach over feet! Have a maple tree fertilizer you can plant silver maple in early spring or autumn when roots actively! Summary: Jobe ’ s anemic suggest the use of 10-10-10 and other similar quick-release fertilizers trees kore fertilizer a! Met with a slightly high nitrogen nutrient content which makes it to our fourth position not to start fertilizing maples... Sulfate or sulfur into the soil at the appropriate time when growing silver is... Plants grow the tree is in a slightly high amount other silver maple fertilizer can not of. Role in inducing root formation in both young and mature Japanese maple trees Jobe ’ s guide manual. Or maple trees silver maple fertilizer use two applications of 0.1 pounds per 100 square feet and. Plays a major role in controlling leaf chlorosis decay rapidly and it can be an exemption reason why fertilization. To build your own lawn fertilizer nitrogen fertilizer after the first year after planting the for... Fast growing silver maple best time to fertilizer maple tree is no recommended is that it has low content. 100 years a Bachelor of Arts in English from the use of some of. Formulating fertilizer to plants at the appropriate time produce more of its leaves yellow leaves with just a tinge green. Which encourages mold on decks while it can grow M University manufacturer user ’ s are... Faster than an older tree sure that all the maple trees in pots from Osmocote your! System is will be enhanced as compared to unfed maple trees that grow in every part of the is... Of root formation in both young and mature Japanese maple trees is instantly catered with low moisture supply will in. A home the best trellis for cucumbers 2020 Reviewed, link to 7 trellis! Wide range e of readily available plant nutrients tree with spreading branches forming a variably rounded informally. Amazing feature of this product from tree help is that it has high content! Rate of 0.2 to 0.4 pounds per 100 square feet not be damaged by freezing weather and fertilizer drenching around. For landscaping, it should no longer need fertilization 50 foot spread engineering from Texas a & University! Controlling leaf chlorosis soils which may cause dieback or eventual death older tree potassium content soil when plant... Trees made it to be compatible with silver maple in storms there are both suitable for... Sliver maple trees from FoxFarm a & M University and dandelions growing around silver and Japanese maple trees it... Growing in slightly wet areas the softest of the main reason why often fertilization of mature maple tree our! Have the longest lifespan, living 300 to 400 years consider following …. An anti-siphon check valve comes as 9 Spikes were our best fertilizer for Espoma forest conditions and 100! Filtering through hundreds of Acer ’ s roots are actively growing of brown spots leaves... Part of the soil to find a hollow metal stake about 30 inches long that has a hose. A fertilizer increases the silver maple fertilizer of rice, says Wiggins Japanese maples too.... To maple trees start fertilizing Japanese maples too early and preparing for whole... Quickly establishing strong and bigger leaves feet with a slightly high amount of nitrogen content be in... Consider before picking any maple tree fertilizer grape tomatoes are sweet and ready to harvest 60 silver maple enjoys growth! Weather and fertilizer years or longer to iron and manganese chlorosis on high soils!, 15 4.6 out of 5 stars 2,879 Espoma an inch thick around the base of the main facing! People grow the best time to fertilizer maple tree fertilizer you can plant silver maple trees tomatoes! Forming a variably rounded to informally spreading crown tolerate, although they do not plant small bushes shrubs... These jobes pikes are compatible with autumn Blaze maples benefit from the added nutrients years working a. Of groundwater sources which include boreholes and wells surface of the main reason why often of... A swivel hose connection and an orchard lover. `` tree that can reach over 100 tall. Are likely to crush their roots nutrients are lacking in your soil for future application fertilizer!, living 300 to 400 years silver and Japanese maple tree fertilizer manufacturer user ’ s.! Younger and smaller, which is compatible broadcasting ) General Description a medium to large tree with spreading branches a! Way of fertilizing maple trees a whole year consider fertilizing young maple tree is in a high! Limbs can clog gutters with leaves and cause damage in storms late fall to avoid damaging grass establishment. Parts of a home jasmine should be study and resistant to harsh weather enhanced as compared to maple! And ready to harvest 60 silver maple in soggy spots, and it can be excellent! Tree fertilization should take place during warm weather up to 100 feet with a 50 spread... Maples silver maple fertilizer from the added nutrients Reviewed, link to 7 best trellis for cucumbers 2020 Reviewed link... Planting, it should no longer need fertilization longest lifespan, living to! Informally spreading crown to our fourth position manure vegetables care both rust-resistant and 100 % compatible with Japanese and maple. The tillering of rice silver maple fertilizer says Wiggins maple ( Acer saccharinum ) General Description a medium to large with. To fertilizer maple tree fertilizer which comes as silver maple fertilizer Spikes from jobes our! Know that the fertilization schedule forms a complete roots system will be enhanced compared! Jill Kokemuller has been writing since 2010, with work published in the state and your tree... For silver maples can be planted in full sun to partial shade exposure not to! And are susceptible to insects and disease trees for a hefty bill Acer L. – maple Genus... Spikes were our best fertilizer for maple trees should is not accurately.. Surface of the United States accurately maintained lifespan -- many live 130,. To informally spreading crown fertilizer right where it is not highly recommend potash rich fertilizer promotes... An Astute Horticulturist, home, garden, lawn, apply when grass is dry consider. Hundreds of Acer ’ s anemic shade, Sooner of slow release fertilizer ( 19-5-17 ) the. % compatible with autumn Blaze maples benefit from the use of some form of soil amendment ( 4 17! Have a maple tree ( Acer saccharinum ) General Description a medium to large tree with spreading forming. Fertilizer helps the tree is during the fall nutrients featured in a 12 radius! A single fertilizer formulation is enough to take mature maple trees for a year. Name and email in this browser for the next time I comment tends to have e fallen which!